We expect modern electronic and electrical systems to be energy efficient and require minimal preventative maintenance. How true is this of a modern high-efficiency uninterruptible power supply?
It is important to remember that a UPS system is a critical device and one that is deployed to provide backup power in the event of a mains power failure. When there is a power outage, the UPS is the most immediate source of stored energy. The device must perform in order to prevent an outage and downtime.
Modern power electronics and manufacturing techniques have resulted in the very high efficiency UPS systems we have today. Whether the UPS is a monoblock or modular UPS design, the system will include an array of monitoring and advanced management systems, designed to improve operational efficiency and improve working life expectancy.
However sophisticated these are, and some firmware may include predictive algorithms, the fact is that uninterruptible power supplies have consumable parts that required regular inspection and replacement. If consumables are not replaced due to operational and maintenance budgets, failure of the uninterruptible power supply becomes inevitable.
For a UPS system the primary consumable is the battery set. This will most likely be a valve regulated lead acid (VRLA) battery. Lithium UPS batteries are becoming more popular but in the main a VRLA battery is still the most widely adopted. If we are looking at a lead acid battery, its replacement timeframe will depend upon several factors including design life, operational room ambient temperature and the number of charge and discharge cycles the battery set has been subjected to.
Most single and some three phase UPS systems use a 5-year design life VRLA battery. What this means is that battery is designed to last up to 5 years when operated at 20-25˚C and for number of charge/discharge cycles (typically 300-400). Most 5-year battery replacements take place within 3-4 years of installation. For a 10-year design life battery, the replacement is typically made within 7-8 years of installation.
High temperatures have a detrimental effect on batteries. For every 1˚C rise above 30˚C the design life halves. It is important to ensure that there is adequate air flow around a UPS battery installation as they are exothermic on discharge. Within a confined space such as a server rack, the should also be enough provision for precision cooling to achieve a 20-25˚C ambient.
Other consumables within a UPS system includes cooling fans and AC and DC capacitors. Both items have a design life and mean time between failure (MTBF). UPS maintenance schedules will take this into account and the UPS itself may also include fan monitoring to alarm when there is a failure. Most UPS include multiple cooling fans; speed controlled and temperature compensating.
Fans and capacitors are typically replaced within years 8-10 as part of a refurbishment. Whilst the fans are generally sealed units their bearings wear over time and within dusty environments, it may be necessary to replace fans earlier. Capacitor failure can lead to a fire risk and potentially a complete system failure due to their power density and concentration of flammable film which tends to be polypropylene.
Preventative maintenance is the key to the long-term viability of an uninterruptible power supply. Most sites are visited annually with some critical datacentres, usually higher tier-rated sites, opting for six monthly visits. During a typical UPS preventative maintenance visit the UPS engineer will typically carry out the following:
Another important factor when considering UPS maintenance is the use of a manufacturer certified engineer. Whilst the service may cost more, the use of certified personnel ensures that the engineers have access to the UPS manufacturer’s technical support team, documentation, firmware updates and approved spares. This also ensures there are warranty infringements and can provide a warranty for any rectification work that is back-to-back with the UPS manufacturer themselves.
There are several types of UPS maintenance contract available and these essentially provide different speeds of response, parts and labour cover and overall support. Whilst these are standard UPS contracts, they can generally be tailored to suit individual sites and specific Service Level Agreements (SLAs).
|UPS Maintenance Contract||Platinum Level||Gold Level||Silver Level||Bronze Level|
|Preventative Maintenance||1 per annum||1 per annum||1 per annum||–|
|Emergency Response||4clock hours||8 working hours||12 working hours||best endeavours|
|24/7 technical hotline||included||included||included||working hours|
|Battery Cover||extra cost||extra cost||extra cost||–|
|On-site Crash Kits||option||option||option||option|
|247 Remote Monitoring||option||option||option||included|
|Monthly Status Report||option||option||option||alerts reported|
|Individual Battery Testing||option||option||option||–|
|Load Bank Testing||option||option||option||–|
The ultimate level of UPS contract tied to a service level agreement is ‘Diamond’. This includes Platinum features and offers a guaranteed fix time. For some sites, faster response times up to 2 clock hours may be available dependent upon the distance from the site of a UPS maintenance engineer or service depot.
For any power protection plan it is important to consider all the elements within the critical power path. A chain is only as strong as its weakest link. If there is a standby power generator, this also needs to be placed under a generator service contract and one that is similar if not matching to the terms of the UPS maintenance contract. Most generators will require inspection at least every year if not six-monthly. It is also important to regularly start and test the generator to ensure there are no start-up or power-down issues. Testing can be done during a preventative maintenance visit using either the ‘live’ or a ‘dummy’ load test bank.
Most three phase UPS systems and some single-phase UPS will have a built-in maintenance bypass. This will isolate the UPS during maintenance to allow the system to be worked on safely. An external UPS maintenance bypass is always a preferred addition. This may or may not use Castell interlocking with local LV switchgear.
External UPS maintenance bypass switches area available to match 1/1, 3/1 or 3/3 configured UPS installations. The benefit of this type of maintenance bypass is that the external switch allows complete electrical isolation and if necessary, the removal and replacement of the uninterruptible power supply without disruption to the connected loads. Furthermore, any such work can be completed during normal working hours rather than outside working hours which can incur further costs.
UPS monitoring software can be deployed to further enhance alarm reporting, fault finding and overall speed of response. The UPS may be installed with an SNMP card to provide a local IP network connection or a GSM modem for remote connection to a cloud-based UPS monitoring package.
Regular maintenance is critical to the availability and resilience of an uninterruptible power supply and should be budgeted for at the time of purchase. The contract should include all labour and parts and may also be priced to include consumable items including at least one fully battery set replacement. Without regular maintenance sudden failures can occur with over 80% caused by a poorly maintained battery set.
When you purchase a UPS system or any other type of capital goods like a precision cooling system, it is important to consider what is referred to in engineering as the bathtub curve. Why is this important? Well at some point during the working life of your new system you may have an alarm condition that requires technical support and an emergency call out and if you are not covered by a UPS maintenance contract then this could be a chargeable service.
With winter upon us it is surprising how many uninterruptible power supplies are in use and not regularly maintained. Not surprising a lot of these UPS systems tend to be the smaller single phase and three phase UPS systems that can be scattered across a large site or hidden away in server racks and computer rooms.